Overview

The Sugar Shack Of White Lake, nestled at 237 White Lake Dr in Elizabethtown, NC, is a charming ice cream shop that perfectly blends quality, atmosphere, and community spirit. This modest yet inviting spot has earned its place as a must-visit for locals and vacationers alike, offering a refreshing escape fueled by excellent ice cream and genuine friendliness.

At the heart of their menu, the Dot Sundae and the Strawberry Ice Cream stand out as favorites that capture both classic indulgence and fresh, fruity delight. Fans often praise the perfect serving temperatures and the generous portions, which make each bite satisfying without ever feeling rushed. Whether you opt for a traditional cone, a waffle cone, or a cup, the texture and flavor maintain a consistently high standard.

The experience at The Sugar Shack Of White Lake is about more than just ice cream. The space invites you to linger—either seated inside in the cool or on the porch's wooden rocking chairs, watching the world go by. It’s a cozy spot that welcomes families, groups, and solo visitors who appreciate that simple pleasure of a sweet treat accompanied by warm service and a relaxed vibe.

Customer reviews reveal this establishment’s unique strength: the staff’s positive attitude and the approachable pricing. Many customers describe visits as a highlight during family getaways or group outings, with some even calling it a community treasure that competes with national favorites in both taste and service quality. The upbeat energy from the team, combined with a diverse roster of flavors and toppings, makes for a memorable stop—especially for the younger crowd who enjoys fun offerings like Dippin' Dots alongside traditional scoops.

In essence, The Sugar Shack Of White Lake is more than just an ice cream shop. It is a gathering place where simple pleasures meet heartfelt hospitality. Whether you’re seeking a thick, indulgent milkshake, a classic sundae, or just a cool spot to unwind after a day at the lake, this humble establishment delivers on all fronts.


What Customers Say

Shelly Carp
Dec 3,2025
4/5
Great ice cream and great pricing...part of our annual.family getaway
Rip Rainey
Dec 3,2025
5/5
The value is amazing. I am convinced this establishment could help with world hunger.....I mean $4 for a pint of ice cream served at the perfect temperature with a smile and 3 min before closing time!!!! Great staff attitude. BTW it was our entire tennis camp of 12 so "well done"
Kenny Hawley
Dec 3,2025
5/5
The Reese’s peanut butter cup shake was amazing and very thick, but I’ve seen collapsed lungs that work better than the straws they give you here to drink milkshakes. Music playing was like thrifty nickel version of Nickelback, oh wait that’s country music. Nevermind … anyways the ice cream is fantastic! Come check ‘im out!
Shawn Jessup
Dec 3,2025
5/5
Great little place for ice cream. Nice selection of flavors and toppings. The kids like the Dippin dots. You can get your ice cream in a regular cone or a waffle cone or a cup if you like. You can sit inside in the cool or out on the porch in the rocking chairs. It's one of the places we have to stop every time we are at White Lake on vacation!
Cassie Hale
Dec 3,2025
4/5
Good place for ice cream. Better than the DQ and their service. If your going to get ice cream please go to the Sugar Shack. Better service and ice cream
Dylan Robbins
Dec 3,2025
5/5
The best ice cream place in Olive White lake. Especially on those hot days. It really hits the spot and it's very budget friendly. I extremely enjoyed their classic ice creams all the way up to their Sundays. Me and my family have been multiple times and are never disappointed. If you're in White lake looking for something to eat, especially a sweet treat. I would absolutely take a look at this place.
Pat Wade
Dec 3,2025
5/5
My husband and I love the ice cream here. Very reasonable cost too. I highly recommend the coffee flavor, my husband loves the strawberry flavor.
Tab Mcghee
Dec 3,2025
5/5
Great place for some delicious frozen treats. They have a variety of desserts to chose from. We had the Philadelphia water ice, vanilla ice-cream with sprinkles, and butter pecan ice-cream. All of the ice-cream was hand dipped which is what we prefer. Everything was delicious! The staff were super friendly and quick to get the orders filled. A nice place to visit for a frozen treat especially during the summer months.

Leave a Review

Location

Opening Hours

Updating...
Top Picks for You

More Ice Cream Shops in Elizabethtown, North Carolina, USA

Handpicked spots for food lovers. Your next favorite meal awaits!